Do you need a fractional CMO, an agency or an in-house lead?
The ad team wants more spend, the website team wants a new page, and nobody has made the budget call. We provide fractional leadership and agency delivery, so we have a commercial interest in this choice. A fractional chief marketing officer (CMO) is a part-time lead who fits when big calls come weekly or monthly and another team can carry out the work. An agency fits when you already have a lead and need delivery. Hire an in-house lead when decisions about staff, customers and priorities come daily.
Francisco Contreras · Founder, Machina
6 min read

Start with the decision nobody owns
Take the approvals that stalled last week and sort them by what was missing. A page waiting to be built needs a delivery owner. A dispute over which channel gets more spend needs a lead who can make that call. A choice tied to today’s sales conversations or staff capacity may need someone inside the business. We start with those actual decisions, not with a title.
These roles can overlap. An agency can provide the senior lead as well as the team that carries out the work. Ask whether its proposal names that person, gives them authority across channels, tells you when they can make the big calls, and says which decisions still need your approval.
Choose part-time leadership when the plan, budget and partners need a senior owner, but the main decisions can be made weekly or monthly. Buy a defined delivery scope when that owner is already in place. Hire an in-house lead when sales, staff and changing priorities need daily decisions. Those responsibilities can sit in a mixed team.
Write down the unresolved decision in one sentence. “Which market gets the next campaign?” needs a lead. “Who will build the campaign after we choose?” needs a delivery team. If you cannot answer the first, buying more production may make the confusion more expensive.
Compare the same responsibilities across all three options
The title on a proposal tells you little about authority. Use this table as a starting brief, then replace each suggested owner with a named person and the actual scope. “Shared” is not an owner until you specify who decides when the parties disagree.
| Responsibility | Fractional CMO | Delivery agency | In-house lead |
|---|---|---|---|
| Decision rights | Sets priorities and directs the plan within agreed authority | Decides how to execute its agreed scope and raises changes to the plan | Makes or recommends daily choices within the authority leadership gives the role |
| Budget ownership | Moves spend between channels within the total budget leadership approves | Manages only the spend and fees named in its agreement | Tracks spend and proposes changes with direct knowledge of company constraints |
| Reporting | Joins channel activity to business outcomes and names the next decision | Reports on its deliverables and agreed measures | Connects internal records, team context and outside reports |
| Delivery | Directs internal and outside specialists and may bring a team for assigned work | Produces the pages, campaigns or other work in scope | Produces work the role can cover and briefs specialists for the rest |
Use this as a brief and name the decision maker, their authority and the work each team will deliver.
The business sets commercial goals, approves the total budget and owns the customer relationship. Leadership can delegate decisions within limits. Write down who may move spend between channels, who may pause a campaign, who approves a claim, and when an exception returns to the person signing the checks. A fractional lead cannot be accountable for choices they are never allowed to make.
If the leadership seat is open, see what our fractional CMO engagement covers. To compare the cost and workload of a direct hire with an outside team, use our agency-versus-hire guide alongside this responsibility brief.
Follow the path from an ad or page to a person who responds
We serve as fractional CMO for Lil Pals Pet World and 101 Exterminators. At 101, we built local service pages across four counties, ran paid media and connected website forms and calls to qualification and office confirmation. We added an optional call center because older customers preferred to phone. That choice connected the way people found the business to the way they wanted a response.
In our leadership work, we follow that entire customer path before setting the next priority. A paid campaign needs a page for the right service area. A form or call needs a response owner. The office needs to know which inquiries became jobs. When a handoff breaks, we name who will repair it and who will check the record afterward.
Ask a prospective lead how they would settle a real disagreement between channels. They should name the evidence they would request, the decision they would defer and the person who can approve a change. Their report should show who chose the next move.
Keep control of the accounts and the business record
Keep a company administrator on the advertising and measurement accounts, give each partner the access their work needs, and review it when people change. In Google Ads, an administrator can change or remove a user’s access. In Google Analytics 4, an account-level grant includes every property, while a property-level grant stays with that property. Decide who can change campaign spend and who can change the reports leadership uses.
We tag every inquiry with what brought it in and follow it to whether it became business. Compare the marketing report with the sales record. If an inquiry is missing, name the person who will find it and the person who can change the reporting rule.
Ask for an exit handoff before work starts. It should cover accounts, current campaigns, assets, decisions in flight and the next action for each. This matters with an employee, a fractional lead and an agency. The business should be able to continue when any one person changes.
Test the authority behind the proposal
Give each candidate or provider the same short scenario. Say that paid inquiries are rising, the sales team says the jobs are a poor fit, and the website report shows more inquiries than the sales record. Ask what they would inspect before increasing spend. The useful answer separates a counting problem from a customer-fit problem, names who can check the records, and says which decision can wait.
For a fractional lead, ask who they will direct, which budget changes need your approval and what they will bring to a leadership review. For a delivery agency, ask which part of that scenario its team would diagnose or fix under the proposed scope. For a hire, ask how the person would work with sales on the missing records while keeping existing campaigns running. Listen for a named owner and an observable next check.
We expect the same test of our own delivery teams. If the evidence argues for changing a page, a campaign or a partner, we want that decision visible to leadership. Separate the leadership decision from the production assignment so the business can see whether each team still fits the plan.
Make the choice from the work in front of you
Put the proposed lead’s decision rights beside the delivery team’s scope. Name the budget they can recommend or move, the people they direct, the report they owe and the work your staff keeps. If the proposal cannot name those boundaries, ask for them before agreeing to the role.
Bring one unresolved decision and one recent report. If you need someone to lead the whole program, reach out to Machina and tell us which budget call or handoff nobody owns today.
Keep reading
Related guides
Explore related work
Next steps
Let's talk about your project
Tell us what you're working on. We'll tell you if we can help — and exactly what we'd do.
