SEO consultant or SEO agency? Choose by who does the work
The proposal names the pages, but the release date is close and nobody owns the changes. We offer consulting and hands-on SEO. Choose consulting when your team can publish and needs direction. Choose agency delivery for work your team cannot staff. Name the owner and the release check before signing.
Francisco Contreras · Founder, Machina
4 min read

Find out who can take the first task
When we rebuilt the Veterans Transition Center website, we ran the full audit and built the redirect map from 51 old addresses to 26 new pages. The center’s team reviewed and revised every redirect. We put the permanent redirects in place and checked every destination before the July 2026 launch. Take one task from the proposal on your desk and ask who can carry it through release.
Ask your writer when a brief could become an approved page and your developer which release could include the fix. Check both dates before you budget for advice. If your team cannot take the first task within the release window, buy delivery for that task.
Sometimes the gap is narrow. If your writers can revise pages and your web team can publish them, a consultant can help select the pages and review the revisions. If a change to the site’s navigation needs development time you cannot get, hire someone to make that change and keep the writing in-house. One provider can cover both kinds of work if the scope names each responsibility.
Compare both proposals against the same work
Send each provider the same first assignment. If both proposals say “improve service pages,” ask each to name the pages, say who drafts and publishes the edits, and show what it would bring to the first review. Compare the hours your writers, developers and approvers would still owe under each scope.
| Responsibility | Consulting scope | Agency delivery scope |
|---|---|---|
| Decide priorities | Consultant diagnoses the problem and ranks the work with your lead. | Agency proposes the order for the work it will deliver. Your lead approves the priorities. |
| Make the change | Your writers or developers carry out the work. The consultant reviews it if agreed. | Agency staff write or build the changes listed in scope. Name any work left with your team. |
| Approve and publish | Your company approves the change and your release owner puts it live. | Your company approves the change. Name the agency or client release owner based on who can publish. |
| Check and review | Agree who checks the live change, then have the consultant read results with your team. | Ask the agency to verify the live work it delivers and bring the agreed measures to review. |
The consulting column is how we run SEO consulting. Confirm both columns in the scope.
An agency can prepare a change while your staff still controls the release. If only your developer has permission to update the live site, put that developer’s time in both proposals. Ask who takes the task back when a release check fails and who gets to decide whether the release goes ahead.
Ask us to show you a past recommendation and how we checked what happened after it went live. Ask the same of anyone you are considering. For an initial audit, give us read-only access to Search Console. We can diagnose the site before anyone grants permission to change it. Discuss publishing permissions when the scope names a task that requires them.
Put the first handoff in writing
Copy this row into your brief for each proposed change. Give the first task a due date and write its evidence as a page address, report or documented problem the next person can open. In the owner column, name who makes the change and who checks it. Add the approver and release date if someone else controls when it goes live.
| Task and due date | Evidence | Owner and checker | Dependency | Release check |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Put the approved redirects live by launch | Map of 51 old addresses to 26 new pages | Release developer makes the change. A second person checks it against the map. | Approved map and ready destination pages | After release, each old address goes directly to its assigned page |
The first row uses our Veterans Transition Center map as an example assignment. We checked destinations before launch. The second-person check after release is our recommended handoff.
For a site move, use permanent redirects wherever technically possible. Once they are live, test the old addresses against the map.
Under a consulting scope, your developer owns the live change while we review the map and the work before release.
What we hand over to the people who publish
We join the planning meeting where search work competes for time and help make the case for it. If a new article and a migration fix share a release, we put the fix first when a page people already use would otherwise open to an error.
We bring evidence to that decision. We look at what customers search for, which pages already bring visits, how the site works and how your team counts leads or sales. We rank the work with your team, name its owners and dependencies, then review briefs, drafts and development tickets before release.
After release, we compare search and conversion measures with the starting point we agreed on and set the next priorities. For a site move, put the launch-day redirect check beside the later comparison of visits to the moved pages. Agree on the pages and dates before launch. If the release includes new service pages, record that change alongside the results.
Choose help for the responsibility you need filled
Bring the filled row back to the proposal. If your team can do the work and needs someone to rank it and review it, see how our SEO consulting fits the handoff. If the work still has no available writer or developer, ask for a delivery scope that names who will do it and who will check it after release. Settle any company approvals before agreeing to the date.
When you reach out to Machina, tell us which change is waiting, what you have checked so far and who on your team can carry it out.
Keep reading
Related guides
Explore related work
Next steps
Let's talk about your project
Tell us what you're working on. We'll tell you if we can help — and exactly what we'd do.
