How to decide where the next marketing dollar goes
The budget is fixed, but every channel wants a larger share. We decide the next move by checking what a paid job leaves after costs, how much work the team can take and where inquiries stall. Then we name the spend to pause and the observation that would change the call.
Francisco Contreras · Founder, Machina
5 min read

Find where buyers are being lost
A channel report can make more spend look obvious while the sales team is missing calls or turning away work it cannot take. We ask which customers the business can serve, what remains after serving them, and where an interested buyer stops moving forward. That tells us whether to buy more demand, improve the offer or page, repair follow-up, or check the reporting.
If suitable inquiries arrive and the team has room, test additional demand. If the team is full, improve capacity or the mix of jobs before buying more inquiries. If inquiries go unanswered, repair that handoff. If nobody can match a claimed lead to a sales record, check the count before ranking channels.
We name what will be paused to fund the move and who can approve it. The person running the work states what will change. The team receiving inquiries agrees on what counts as a good fit. The review then has a real choice to make about continuing, changing or stopping.
Use a budget decision sheet
Copy the fields below once for each spending option, including the work you could stop to pay for it. A paid job is work finished and paid for. Subtract every cost that rises with one more job, such as parts and hourly labor, from the revenue received. That is the per-unit contribution used in the Small Business Administration’s break-even calculator. Count the full proposed marketing cost, including fees. For repeat purchases, use a period you can actually observe. Leave hoped-for future sales out of this month’s budget.
| Field | Hypothetical search test | Your option |
|---|---|---|
| Current spend to pause | $600 on broad social during the last complete month. No paid repair jobs appear in the job log. | Channel, full cost, period and paid work ______ |
| Proposed use | Move that $600 to a repair-search test, including all fees | Use and full cost ______ |
| Margin per paid job | $800 received less $300 in costs that rise with each job (parts and hourly labor) = $500 | Revenue received less all costs that rise with each job ______ |
| Capacity | Three open repair slots during the test period | Open jobs or orders in the same period ______ |
| Follow-up | Office manager answers calls and records paid jobs | Person and sales record ______ |
| Decision owner | Owner approves the move. Marketing lead runs the test. | Approver and operator ______ |
| Next observation | After the jobs have time to close and be paid, compare additional paid repair jobs with the prior comparable period. Review call handling too. | Record, review date and decision rule ______ |
Machina decision sheet. All amounts, jobs and roles in the filled column are hypothetical. Enter your own verified records in the final column.
In this hypothetical example, one additional paid job leaves $500 before marketing cost and falls $100 short of the $600 test. Two leave $1,000 and cover it by $400. The team has room for three, so the spend could pay for itself within its available capacity. The test still has to bring in those two jobs.
If the office is already missing calls, put response work on another copy of the sheet and compare it with the search test. One strong month can be seasonal, as the FDIC’s marketing-plan module cautions, so we set a review date before a test becomes a standing expense.
When the records disagree or several teams own parts of the decision, our marketing strategy consultation turns one budget question into a written plan. Bring the current allocation, a sales record and the decision you need to make. Your plan names where to spend, what to cut to pay for it and the evidence behind each choice.
Check the jobs behind the channel report
We compare spend and reported inquiries with signed jobs before shifting money between channels. A signed job shows the business accepted the work. The payment record shows what came in. A platform total counts actions under its reporting rules. Keep both records and the date range visible. If they disagree, trace a sample inquiry from the form or call through the person who answered it to the signed job.
In the hypothetical sheet, no paid repair jobs appear under broad social. We would check the calls and job records, the services those buyers wanted, and the period before making the cut.
When the job log is incomplete, pay to make it usable before expanding a channel. Record where the inquiry came from, whether anyone responded, whether it was a fit, whether it became a signed job, and whether the work was completed and paid. Our guide to MER and ROAS explains why a channel return and a whole-business spending ratio answer different questions.
Let the business problem set the sequence
When retail and wholesale softened for Gloria, an Italian wine-based hard seltzer, its existing online store was not selling enough to carry the business. The product and inventory were in place. We put purchase tracking on the store before moving the budget. Then we led with paid social, the only lever that could move volume within a quarter. We did the identity work after seeing what buyers responded to.
When we built the program for 101 Exterminators, a new company without walk-in traffic needed people across four counties to find it and get a response. We joined city pages, local search and paid media with inquiry qualification, an optional automated phone line for customers who preferred to call, and office confirmation. A budget sheet for that work needs to account for acquisition, response and the team that takes the jobs.
We ask which part of that path is ready for more volume and which part is losing people. A team with unanswered calls needs a different first purchase from a store with inventory, measured purchases and room to sell more.
Move the money with a review date
Name the line item to pause, the work to fund, the person who can make the change and the date of the next review. Compare paid work with the full cost and the capacity that was available. If the expected work does not arrive or the team cannot take it, change the allocation. When the records are too thin to choose, pay for the missing check first.
Copy the sheet for the budget choices in front of you. If several channels or teams have a claim on the same money, reach out to Machina with the spend you might move, the job records you trust and the decision the plan must settle.
Keep reading
Related guides
Explore related work
Next steps
Let's talk about your project
Tell us what you're working on. We'll tell you if we can help — and exactly what we'd do.
